Skip to main content

Advertisement

Advertisement

Modi’s 100 days in office marked by fresh economic confidence

When the talk turns to China, you can tell India is feeling improved. During Delhi’s late 2000s boom, bullish types often said Asia’s third-largest economy would overtake its larger neighbour’s double-digit growth rates. It never did. Instead, years of political drift and a spate of graft scandals left Indian optimists chastened.

When the talk turns to China, you can tell India is feeling improved. During Delhi’s late 2000s boom, bullish types often said Asia’s third-largest economy would overtake its larger neighbour’s double-digit growth rates. It never did. Instead, years of political drift and a spate of graft scandals left Indian optimists chastened.

Those comparisons with China are making a minor comeback, reflecting new-found energy under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who marked 100 days in office yesterday. But they are also potentially worrying signs of overconfidence in a recovery that remains both gradual and fragile.

The immediate cause for the latest wave of euphoria arrived last Friday, with data showing India expanding at an unexpectedly buoyant 5.7 per cent in the first quarter, its best figures since early 2012. Industrial growth jumped too, after two flat years.

Mr Arun Jaitley, the Finance Minister, over the weekend predicted further improvements in the next few quarters. Investors agree, pushing shares to record levels on Monday. With China’s economy turning down towards 7 per cent growth, the idea that India might expand more rapidly no longer seems quite so absurd.

Mr Prashant Jain, head of HDFC Mutual Fund, India’s largest asset manager, says his country will do just that in a few years, becoming the world’s fastest-growing large developing economy.

Mr Chetan Ahya, chief economist for Morgan Stanley in Asia, agrees. “Perhaps in three years, as China keeps slowing, yes, India will be growing faster,” he says. “And it could be faster still if the government is bold.”

The irony is that Mr Modi had little, if anything, to do with this bounce. He was not in power for most of the period covered by last Friday’s figures and his administration has made slow progress in reducing the bureaucratic hurdles that hobble investment.

Mr Raghuram Rajan, governor of the Reserve Bank of India who took office a year ago, deserves more credit, having helped restore business confidence with his push to curb inflation. Belated action by the previous government to cut spending helped too, as did an easing of the global pressures that hit India last year, along with other emerging markets.

Yet Mr Modi is responsible for the return of India’s confidence in a broader sense. His overwhelming election victory in May, his gruff sense of purpose, his pro-business reputation; all have lifted spirits. After so many rudderless years, the Prime Minister looks like a leader too, as when he headed to Japan over the weekend with a bevy of tycoons in tow, seeking investment deals.

BOLDER REFORMS REQUIRED

For all that, there are good reasons to be wary of the spring in India’s step. Economists warn that Mr Modi will have to bring in further spending cuts to meet a tighter fiscal deficit target. As a result, the economy may well fall back again over the coming quarters.

Even if it does not, analysts believe there is scant chance of a return to 8 or 9 per cent growth, without reforms of the sort that Mr Modi has thus far avoided, such as reducing labour market restrictions.

Internationally too, the picture is far from benign.

Mr Rajan says India is better prepared for the end of United States ultra-easy monetary policy. But he has still been warning darkly of a possible global crisis when liquidity runs out, while stockpiling dollar reserves — hardly signs of blithe assurance.

Partly for this reason, even the China comparisons are more modest this time, predicting only a gradual convergence of growth rates. Previously, the argument went that India’s economic model would prove superior, boosted by youthful demographics, democratic institutions and proficiency in English. So wrong did these predictions prove, that few are likely to make them again in a hurry.

Instead, the risk is that India’s mini-rebound will lessen pressure on its government to take unpopular decisions. Sceptics say India introduces economic reforms only in the face of calamity, as after its 1991 balance of payments crisis. As he seeks to emulate China, Mr Modi has the ideal opportunity to prove them wrong.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

James Crabtree is the Financial Times’ Mumbai Bureau Chief.

Read more of the latest in

Advertisement

Advertisement

Stay in the know. Anytime. Anywhere.

Subscribe to get daily news updates, insights and must reads delivered straight to your inbox.

By clicking subscribe, I agree for my personal data to be used to send me TODAY newsletters, promotional offers and for research and analysis.